Why should the beautiful die?
Have you ever seen the First National Bank building in Castle Shannon? You can tell it’s a bank by the big box in the pediment marked “VAULT ALARM.” You can see the little bank, its alarm, and its Corinthian columns at FatherPitt.com.
We also have a picture of Holy Rosary Convent in Homewood, a modest Renaissance palace that makes a strong contrast with the flamboyant Gothic of Holy Rosary Church.
After the flamboyant Gothic of Holy Rosary, this stately Renaissance palace is quite a contrast.
Ralph Adams Cram was probably the greatest Gothic architect our country ever produced. There are four churches by Cram in Pittsburgh (and one in Greensburg), and each is a masterpiece in its way. East Liberty Presbyterian is overwhelmingly impressive. Calvary Episcopal is restrained and tasteful, a good fit for its low-church Episcopalian congregation. But Holy Rosary seems to be a product of the artist’s pure delight in his medium. It was finished in 1930, when Cram was at the peak of his creative powers.
The church is still in good shape, but it is no longer a worship site, and what can be done with a building this size? The offices of St. Charles Lwanga parish are here, but it is only a matter of time before someone decides that it would be more efficient to have an office building that is less expensive to maintain. Homewood is prospering much more than it was a few years ago, but it has a long way to go before it becomes a rich enough neighborhood to make it worth adapting this building; and any congregation looking for a church would have to have a high budget to maintain this one. (St. Charles Lwanga parish worships a few blocks away in the small and undistinguished, but much easier to maintain, Mother of Good Counsel church.)
We hope Holy Rosary will be preserved and restored, but it competes with many other churches and synagogues worthy of preservation and restoration. It is hard to find uses for a building so perfectly adapted to one specific purpose for which it is no longer wanted.
All the niches have lost their statues, which suggests that the parish took them down and reinstalled them elsewhere. Do any St. Charles Lwanga parishioners know the story?
This movie house was newly built in 1915, when this picture was published. It was open until the late 1960s; it was torn down in the 1970s.
There are three Ralph Adams Cram churches in Pittsburgh, but by far the most fantastical of the lot is Holy Rosary in Homewood.
Father Pitt 